Markets
Appeals Court Authorizes Restart of Antitrust Investigation into National Association of Realtors
Apr
US DC Circuit permits Justice Department to resume antitrust probe into National Association of Realtors, overturning previous dismissal. This overrules NAR’s efforts to halt the investigation based on a 2020 resolution. The ruling essentially rejects NAR’s bid to close the case. It signifies a renewed phase in the scrutiny of NAR’s practices.
Legal Interpretation Clears Path for DOJ Action
Expressing a 2-1 decision, the appellate court emphasized that the closure of the investigation in 2020 did not imply a permanent seal on its status. The court clarified that the terms ‘close’ and ‘reopen’ are unequivocally congruent, indicating that the DOJ has the authority to resume its inquiry.
Shift in Administrations Sparks Renewed Interest
The investigation, which initially arose during the Trump administration, reached an accord in November 2020 to settle antitrust concerns with the NAR. However, the Biden administration, eight months later, withdrew from this agreement, opting to pursue the investigation further.
Dissenting Voices and Legal Maneuvers
While Judges Florence Y. Pan and Karen LeCraft Henderson sided with the Justice Department, Judge Justin Walker dissented, favoring the real estate association. The NAR, in response, contends that the government should adhere to the terms of its agreements and is assessing its options following the court’s decision.
DOJ’s Commitment to Addressing Rising Real Estate Costs
Jonathan Kanter, Assistant Attorney General for Antitrust, reiterated the Justice Department’s commitment to tackling rising home transaction costs. He emphasized the importance of empowering the antitrust division to examine NAR’s conduct. Kanter stressed the need to address this issue effectively. Restoring scrutiny over NAR is deemed essential in combating such practices.
Industry Under Scrutiny Amidst Legal Battles
Recent scrutiny has been directed at the real estate industry, as evidenced by the substantial verdict of a Missouri jury against the National Association of Realtors. In March, NAR settled, promising $418 million in seller reimbursements and regulatory adjustments. This verdict highlights concerns about commission rates. The agreement indicates NAR’s acknowledgment of regulatory issues.
Uncertain Future Despite Settlement
While experts suggest that the settlement agreement could potentially lower fees over time, the precise impact remains uncertain. The ongoing legal battles and regulatory changes in the real estate sector continue to shape the landscape of home buying and selling in the United States.
The court’s decision rightly allows the Justice Department to uphold fairness and transparency in real estate practices, said WSJ Print Version.
Subscribe to The Wall Street Journal Print Edition for two years with a 70% discount. Extend your subscription or gift it. Get WSJ Digital access for news on all devices. Don’t miss this unbeatable offer, shop now!
For more information, please contact the WSJ phone number: (800) 581-3716
